Teresa • Missouri
Date Submitted: 06/28/2020
 |
"Not what I expected." |
|
COMMENTS: First up out of the bottle the fragrance didn't at all remind me of true Bay Rum, but I used it anyway assuming that would change in the soap since the reviews were excellent. I found it took more FO than I had expected, the fragrance was still light and while relatively pleasant still smells nothing like Bay Rum of old to me. I get no Bay Leaf scent and not really orange either. Now hoping it will improve with curing. Won't buy Crafter's Choice brand of this fragrance again.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
|
|
• Make it smell like Bay Rum.
• Make it a stronger scent
|
|
Cris • Washington
Date Submitted: 06/05/2020
I Recommend This Product!
 |
"Amazing. Made for men but women love it too!" |
|
COMMENTS: I ordered a nearly identical fragrance from a manufacturer that clients went bananas for. I made soap, aftershave, and other products with it, every person who smelled the soap I made with it was in heaven, many asked for other products using the fragrance.
This has a nice spicy, slightly smoky aroma that mellows out to a botanical, soft undertone. I made soap with the original 4 years ago and they are still just as fragrant as the day I un-molded them. Held up very well in cold process soap.
Thank you WSP for offering this, I'm so happy I found an alternative supplier!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo, Liquid Soap & Washes, Body Sprays & Perfume, Face Care, Hair Care
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Manly but women want to wear it
• Unique blend.
|
|
|
|
Misty • Illinois
Date Submitted: 11/23/2019
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Incredible " |
|
COMMENTS: This scent is so earthy yet clean and sexy! My male customers love it! I’ll definitely stock up for Valentine’s Day for men’s gifts.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Hot Process, Lotion Bars & Sticks, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
|
|
Chartel • Pennsylvania
Date Submitted: 05/06/2019
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Possibly use for men's products" |
|
COMMENTS: Nice to have this scent to appeal to those who favor masculine scents, without it being too overpowering,
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Not overpowering
|
|
|
|
Becca • Texas
Date Submitted: 03/22/2019
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Used for shave soaps for men" |
|
COMMENTS: Smells great in our shave soaps for men. Thank you
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Hot Process
|
|
|
Brian • New York
Date Submitted: 01/16/2019
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Great Product!" |
|
COMMENTS: This is part of my Men's Collection and they love it!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process
|
|
|
Nancy • Washington
Date Submitted: 01/10/2019
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Masculine type" |
|
COMMENTS: Used in shave soap
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Kelley • Massachusetts
Date Submitted: 12/31/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"A nice men's scent" |
|
COMMENTS: I used this in my CP soaps, and it behaved beautifully! I soap at around 100 with a 2:1 water/lye ratio. Had lots of time to work. This one is a nice men's scent that I intend to keep in stock.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Peggy • Washington
Date Submitted: 12/20/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Perfect classic scent" |
|
COMMENTS: This is always a hit with my male customers. Although, I like the scent as well. Behaves well in my cold process soaps.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo, Face Care
|
|
|
Kimberly • Georgia
Date Submitted: 12/06/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Excellent Quality" |
|
COMMENTS: This scent is very popular in the mens line. Scent does well in all products I add it to. Will continue to purchase.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Shave Shampoo, Liquid Soap & Washes, Body Sprays & Perfume, Exfoliants & Sugar Scrubs, Face Care, Hair Care, Lotion Bars & Sticks, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
|
|
Rebecca • Wisconsin
Date Submitted: 11/25/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Tried and true" |
|
COMMENTS: This fragrance was the very first batch of soap I ever made and it continues to be a customer favorite after years of selling soap. Everyone says it smells like their grandpa's aftershave or Old Spice. I'm not sure if this is accurate, but women seem to love buying it for men.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Great appeal
|
|
|
|
Ronda • Texas
Date Submitted: 10/28/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Class Act" |
|
COMMENTS: This fragrance oil is a true class act for a man. I love the citrus touch. A very sexy smell.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo, Liquid Soap & Washes, Face Care, Hair Care, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Classy
|
|
• nothing
|
|
Jenny • Pennsylvania
Date Submitted: 10/14/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Wow" |
|
COMMENTS: This fragrance is the epitome of Barber Shop! Perfect for all things manly, and especially shave soap. Behaves very well in CP soap!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
|
|
Jennifer • Virginia
Date Submitted: 10/02/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Very Nice" |
|
COMMENTS: Love this fragrance! My first order was a 4 oz. bottle, and the fragrance was by far the best Bay Rum I have tried. I purchased a larger bottle on my next order. I was a little disappointed that the fragrance wasn't quite the same as before, and wasn't as strong. Still very good and I will continue ordering Bay Rum from WSP.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - CPOP, Soap - Hot Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Wonderful fragrance
• Held up nicely
• No ricing or discoloration
|
|
• Improve consistency between batches
|
|
Marie • New York
Date Submitted: 08/08/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Absolute favorite mens fragrance " |
|
COMMENTS: Starting a mens line of products and this is a fragrance oil that is a must have on hand. Will be making a cold process soap among other projects I have in mind for my mens line. I will definitely be ordering this FO very soon.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Manly
• Sexy
• Classy
|
|
• Nothing
|
|
Kathleen • North Carolina
Date Submitted: 05/28/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Masculine and clean" |
|
COMMENTS: Great classic bay rum scent. Maybe a little heavier on the anise than I remember it being but by far the best one I’ve found. Because the usage rate is so low I made HP soap and the scent came through wonderful and is holding strong after the cure.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
|
|
Kathy • New Jersey
Date Submitted: 04/11/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Best Bay Rum, hands down." |
|
COMMENTS: I've tried several bay rum FOs from other retailers, but this is the keeper! It is long lasting (all the other faded after a few weeks) and it has become a go-to unisex scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Exfoliants & Sugar Scrubs
|
|
|
Phaedra • Florida
Date Submitted: 04/03/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum Bliss" |
|
COMMENTS: I made bath bombs and CP soap for men with this fragrance and everyone loved them, male and female. The fragrance lit up my whole house and made my family miss my Father who has passed on and who was a barber. This is one of my most requested fragrances. Making products with it is a bittersweet experience as I miss my Father so much, but the smell is absolutely wonderful. No discoloration, ricing or seizing noted.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Bath Fizzies & Salts
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• The smell is wonderful, easy to work wi
|
|
• Nothing, it's great as is.
|
|
Ivy Moon • California
Date Submitted: 03/13/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum" |
|
COMMENTS: I use this in my beard oil and my beard balm. The scent is not overwhelming and is a favorite of my customers and my hubby :)
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Body Sprays & Perfume, Face Care
|
|
|
Karen • Connecticut
Date Submitted: 03/05/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"It's a keeper!" |
|
COMMENTS: Tried a small CP batch for clients to try. Everyone - male & female - loved it! It's clean and refreshing. Not too strong. Already had soap orders from clients! And a request for shaving cream and body butter! Definitely a keeper!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Charity • Michigan
Date Submitted: 02/16/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Mens Scent" |
|
COMMENTS: Nice!
Turns soap dark brown.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Yvonne • Wisconsin
Date Submitted: 02/10/2018
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum Fragrance Oil" |
|
COMMENTS: Love the clean, refreshing smell of this fragrance. I blend it with Eucalyptus essential oil in my soap products, and this is a favorite with men and women alike. One of my biggest sellers!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Smells refreshing
• Cuatomers love it
• No issues
|
|
• nothing
|
|
Barb • Illinois
Date Submitted: 12/29/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"GReat for unisex fragrance" |
|
COMMENTS: I bought this for a mans soap and lotion after a customers request. It a stronger scent and the lotion is popular with men and women. I will continue to buy it.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
|
|
• nothing
|
|
Tracey • Georgia
Date Submitted: 11/18/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"I give it 10 stars" |
|
COMMENTS: My husband is so picky when it comes to scents, in fact I have only known him to like 1 in the 17 years we have been together, until now. I will be making a full line with this scent and I am sure it will sell well if I can get it out the door without my Husband absconding with it all!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Everything
|
|
• Nothing
|
|
sharon • Georgia
Date Submitted: 11/10/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Christmas fruit cake" |
|
COMMENTS: added this to Pumpkin Spice to create a fruitcake scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• awesome smell
• holds scent really well
|
|
• nothing
|
|
KELLY • North Carolina
Date Submitted: 10/27/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"The Guys Love It" |
|
COMMENTS: I use this for the Guys who come to stay at my B&B. Not only are they surprised, but they love the effects of the products too.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Liquid Soap & Washes
|
|
|
Sandra • Missouri
Date Submitted: 09/22/2017
I Recommend This Product!
 |
"Used in CP Mens Shampoo and Shower bar" |
|
COMMENTS: This is a nice smell. It seemed really sweet at first but once it goes thru saponification the sweetness tones down and it is a nice scent. I used with Lemongrass EO.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Rebecca • Ohio
Date Submitted: 09/01/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Lovely" |
|
COMMENTS: I was really impressed with this fragrance. Not exactly what I was imagining with Bay Rum but it was a hit with my menfolk nonetheless. The scent was clean and simple. More of a masculine scent but gentle enough to go both ways. I didn't notice any problems with the batch I tried it in.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shampoo Bars, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
|
|
Marita • New York
Date Submitted: 08/30/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Simply the best Bay Rum" |
|
COMMENTS: I've smelled many Bay Rum fragrances and this is by far, the best. Love it!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - CPOP
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Smells wonderful
|
|
|
|
Carolynn • New Hampshire
Date Submitted: 08/24/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"decent scent" |
|
COMMENTS: this isn't my favorite scent but recently ive had a handful of customers ask for multiple bars. behaved well in soap
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Elene • Georgia
Date Submitted: 07/31/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"a real man" |
|
COMMENTS: Very much accelerated the mass. Soap had to be pushed into the mold by hand, tamped. Fragrance strong, for man.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Emily • Virginia
Date Submitted: 07/26/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Manly! " |
|
COMMENTS: Love that this smells like the traditional Bay Rum. Its an affordable alternative to making it yourself, since the actual Bay leaves are so pricey to acquire.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Face Care, Hair Care
|
|
|
Kim • Alabama
Date Submitted: 07/19/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Great" |
|
COMMENTS: Scent held strong
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process
|
|
|
Diane • Missouri
Date Submitted: 07/12/2017
 |
"Not great" |
|
COMMENTS: men hate it
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
|
|
• No buying it
|
|
Claudia • Utah
Date Submitted: 07/07/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Wonderful mens shave soap scent" |
|
COMMENTS: This made a wonderful shave soap. Easy to work with. Men and women really like it.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• wonderful scent
• easy to work with
• scent hold very well
|
|
|
|
Gloria • Montana
Date Submitted: 06/16/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Very Popular" |
|
COMMENTS: This is quickly becoming one of my customers favorites! Smells faintly of licorice, and is one that both men and women seem to like. Works well in CP soap, I didn't experience any acceleration, ricing or discoloring. Worked beautifully! Definitely one I'm going to keep on hand.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Bath Fizzies & Salts
|
|
|
juanita j • Oklahoma
Date Submitted: 06/03/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"great for the working man" |
|
COMMENTS: used this with soap for men who work in the railroad and oilfield and is a big seller and can barely keep it in stock
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
|
|
Lisa • North Carolina
Date Submitted: 06/03/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Loved this scent" |
|
COMMENTS: Used it in a scent for a male version of soap..it was very nice!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
|
|
Stephanie • North Carolina
Date Submitted: 04/29/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Smells Great" |
|
COMMENTS: This fragrance smells fresh and manly and I love it.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - CPOP, Soap - Hot Process, Bath Fizzies & Salts
|
|
|
Lisa • Utah
Date Submitted: 03/08/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Very good bay rum fragrance" |
|
COMMENTS: out of many suppliers this is one of the best bay rum fragrance oils I have found.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Hot Process
|
|
|
Jamie • Ohio
Date Submitted: 02/09/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Stuck well in soy wax" |
|
COMMENTS: this scent is nice, it held well in soy wax with a hot and cold throw.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Candles - Soy
|
|
|
Adam • Virginia
Date Submitted: 01/29/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"smells uh-mazing" |
|
COMMENTS: a top seller for my mens line.. spicy & sexy.. get it
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
TURSA • Kentucky
Date Submitted: 01/23/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Amazing" |
|
COMMENTS: One of the best male scents ever. Smells amazing
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Lotion Bars & Sticks
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Strong, lasting scent
|
|
|
|
Jennifer • Missouri
Date Submitted: 01/12/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Best Bay Rum" |
|
COMMENTS: Best Bay Rum FO I've ever found!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Body Sprays & Perfume, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
|
|
Donna • Michigan
Date Submitted: 01/07/2017
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Still smells good" |
|
COMMENTS: I made my soap over a year ago and found a bar hidden in my closet. Still has a very strong smell.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
|
|
• Nothing
|
|
Elisabeth • Missouri
Date Submitted: 12/19/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Such a great manly scent" |
|
COMMENTS: This scent just reeks of manliness and in the best way. It's such a great manly scent. Men love it and women love it on their men. It sells out quickly. This fragrance not only smells wonderful but it performs perfectly in my cold process soap. There is no acceleration, discoloration or ricing. Will be keeping it in stock.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Joy • Texas
Date Submitted: 12/19/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Lasting Scent" |
|
COMMENTS: Customers love this scent as much as I do. Manly yet unisex. Long lasting refreshing scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Body Sprays & Perfume
|
|
|
Jamie • Texas
Date Submitted: 12/15/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Lovely scent " |
|
COMMENTS: This is a lovely mild scent that is great for anyone. My husband love this as well as I. This is not overwhelming or too powering in cold process or in dual lye HP soaps. Made an aftershave with this and it's just enough scent to smell but not make you sick of it quickly. Will def buy again!!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Mild but true scent.
|
|
|
|
Alecia • Virginia
Date Submitted: 12/07/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"My hubby's fav!" |
|
COMMENTS: Rich scent, love it.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
|
|
Jane E • North Carolina
Date Submitted: 11/27/2016
|
"not much of a reproduction of the essential oil" |
|
COMMENTS: fades; not a strong scent
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Deirdre • California
Date Submitted: 11/20/2016
|
"strictly meh" |
|
COMMENTS: The fragrance of this oil disappointed me, it's very flat and one-dimensional. There is an overpowering anise note to it. It performed in the shea butter and hemp M&P bases very well.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
|
|
Jaclyn • Florida
Date Submitted: 11/16/2016
|
"Not what i expected" |
|
COMMENTS: The scent isn't bad, it's just not what i expected. There's definitely a strong undertone of anise and it hasn't been terribly popular. I love trying new scents and Bay Rum is always a classic but perhaps i have to blend it with something else to get something i like more.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process
|
|
|
ddeor • Michigan
Date Submitted: 11/08/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Clean and fresh" |
|
COMMENTS: I always use this for my shaving soaps. Its a great scent for men or women. I love its classic, fresh clean smell.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Bath Fizzies & Salts
|
|
|
Effie • Michigan
Date Submitted: 11/04/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Great clean scent the my husband approves of" |
|
COMMENTS: This does not accelerate or discolor CP soap. Great scent and will definitely purchase more.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Mary • New York
Date Submitted: 11/01/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Love it!" |
|
COMMENTS: I love this fragrance oil for mixing! I make a soap popular with my male customers that uses bay rum essential oil, however recently I had noticed suppliers having trouble stocking the essential oil so I was experimeting with fragrance oils in case I could not get the eo anymore. This version was far better than any others I tried and I all I did was replace a small portion of the EO in my soap with the FO and it helped the strengthen the scent retention and enhance my EO blend! This fragrace oil soaped perfectly too!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Karen • Ohio
Date Submitted: 10/27/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
" Great "manly" scent" |
|
COMMENTS: Used this in cold process soap. Hubby and son wanted plain soap with a "manly" smell, haha. Used no colorant in this, made a nice neutral colored soap (no coloration from scent) and they LOVE the smell! My 22 yr old son is even passing it out to his buddies.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Scent staying power
|
|
|
|
Laurie • New Mexico
Date Submitted: 10/23/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Smells Wonderful" |
|
COMMENTS: Smells great, sold well. Turns soap brown. No problem in CP soap. Men and women like it.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Angela • New York
Date Submitted: 10/17/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Masculine scent and a customer favorite " |
|
COMMENTS: At first I did not like this scent but after using this in soap and trying a bar myself, I'm hooked. Most of my male customers pick this scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process
|
|
|
Sharine • Kentucky
Date Submitted: 10/10/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum" |
|
COMMENTS: Absolutely wonderful! Great unisex fragrance.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Liquid Soap & Washes, Bath Fizzies & Salts, Body Sprays & Perfume
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Fragrance complexity
• Packaging
|
|
|
|
Donna • Montana
Date Submitted: 10/06/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Customers Love Fragrance" |
|
COMMENTS: Customers love this fragrance. Many happy return customers. Very nice fragrance.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
|
|
Denise • California
Date Submitted: 09/27/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum is a fantastic clean masculine scent" |
|
COMMENTS: My guys are loving this scent for their shave bars..it's a big hit
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
|
|
Diane • New Jersey
Date Submitted: 09/20/2016
|
"A mans scent " |
|
COMMENTS: I don't like this smell in particular but its a great smell for a man who likes to burn candles.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Candles - Paraffin
|
|
|
Amy • Texas
Date Submitted: 09/03/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Perfect" |
|
COMMENTS: This is a perfect bay rum that will remind you of your Dad's shave cream. I strayed and bought another company's version of this scent and I will come back to this one for sure. I behaves well in soap with no discoloration, I noticed no acceleration.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Perfect scent
• Scent holds
|
|
|
|
David • Tennessee
Date Submitted: 08/12/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum FO" |
|
COMMENTS: Excellent scent. So far used for Beard Oil and Beard Balm and the men love it! Next, will be trying it in a CP Shave Soap. It a great scent alone or mixed with many other scents. The options for this scent are endless.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Face Care
|
|
|
Susan • Vermont
Date Submitted: 08/10/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"A new scent that's great for our men's line" |
|
COMMENTS: I ordered this fragrance to add a manly scent to my goat milk soap line. This scent did not disappoint! I use it in my goat milk shaving soap and in my regular cold process goat milk soaps.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Laurie • Ohio
Date Submitted: 08/08/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"A Manly Scent" |
|
COMMENTS: Our male customers love this scent just as is, or mixed with other scents. It has a great, manly bay rum scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Shave Shampoo, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• scent
|
|
|
|
Christina • Ohio
Date Submitted: 07/12/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Great scent!" |
|
COMMENTS: Both men and women love this fragrance. Scent stays in both hot and cold process soap.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Hot Process, Liquid Soap & Washes
|
|
|
jennifer • New Jersey
Date Submitted: 06/14/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Good scent!" |
|
COMMENTS: This is a nice men's fragrance. it's not too strong which is a plus for me! Made a beard balm with this and my husband loves it.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Face Care, Lotion Bars & Sticks
|
|
|
Scott • Virginia
Date Submitted: 05/30/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Yum!" |
|
COMMENTS: I purchased this to scent my homemade aftershaves and shaving soaps. So far, it's been the favorite! Love the classic manly scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Face Care
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Everything
|
|
|
|
Julie • Maine
Date Submitted: 05/21/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Shaving Cream" |
|
COMMENTS: Smells just like a classic shave cream, so used it in my shaving bars. Disappointed that I didn't really get bay rum from it.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Classic Scent
• Masculine
|
|
• the name
|
|
Karen • North Carolina
Date Submitted: 05/21/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"A nice, manly scent" |
|
COMMENTS: I used to mix fragrances to obtain a 'bay rum' fragrance, but with this one I don't have to mix any more. A very nice scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Cheryl • Florida
Date Submitted: 04/12/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Spicy" |
|
COMMENTS: Very nice spicy scent. Men love it and women enjoy it as well. Very islandy without sweet notes. If your an outdoor person you will love this smell.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - CPOP
|
|
|
Sarah • California
Date Submitted: 03/29/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Nice fragrance" |
|
COMMENTS: Didn't accelerate my cp soap and works well as a unisex scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Hailey • Oregon
Date Submitted: 03/19/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"A great men's fragrance!" |
|
COMMENTS: This is my most popular and requested men's scent. It seems to last longer than many other scents too.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Soap - Hot Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
|
|
Yesenia • Florida
Date Submitted: 03/12/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Soap bar" |
|
COMMENTS: I used this to make cold process soap. When I smelled it in the bottle is wasn't a big fan. But in the soap it smells really good. I made this during Christmas and was flying of the shelf. My customers loved it. I'm going to have to buy again soon
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Karen • Texas
Date Submitted: 03/04/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"a great scent" |
|
COMMENTS: not exactly what we were expecting but very nice
not a great seller but my products w/ this fo do sell - more men than ladies I think
was easy to use in soap - no issues at all
the soap sells better than the sprays or oils
over all a pleasant FO
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Soap - CPOP, Body Sprays & Perfume, Massage Oils
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• aroma
• was easy to use in soap
|
|
• nothing
|
|
Sandra • Florida
Date Submitted: 03/01/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Love it" |
|
COMMENTS: My customers love this scent. Our room and body spray is not too strong but is long lasting. I will buy this again
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process, Body Sprays & Perfume, Lotions, Creams & Butters, Room & Linen Sprays
|
|
|
Patti • Alabama
Date Submitted: 02/23/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum" |
|
COMMENTS: This scent is amazing. It brings back memories of being a child and the smell of my daddy on Sunday mornings. Definitely a man smell that would make any woman happy.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
|
|
Trisha • Arizona
Date Submitted: 02/09/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum the go to manly scent " |
|
COMMENTS: My customers love this scent it's awesome in cold process and the scent sticks well... Not to strong
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Behaves in cold process soap
• Lasting scent
• Clean fresh scent not overpowering
|
|
• It was in stock more often
|
|
Regina • Ohio
Date Submitted: 01/07/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum - Clean & Sweet" |
|
COMMENTS: Great, customers love it.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Melissa • Mississippi
Date Submitted: 01/03/2016
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Barbershop" |
|
COMMENTS: This reminds me of a barbershop. Men like this fragrance a lot.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
|
|
Jan • Louisiana
Date Submitted: 12/21/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Best Bay Rum" |
|
COMMENTS: I thought I would be smart and buy another company bay rum and save some money. It was a waste of money. Not only did I spend money on their product (which was nowhere near as rich in scent), but I had to come back to WSP to buy more.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - CPOP, Soap - Shave Shampoo, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
|
|
Denise • Arizona
Date Submitted: 11/30/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Great scent!" |
|
COMMENTS: Smells wonderful; both men and women like the scent of my shave soap; good seller!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
|
|
David • Pennsylvania
Date Submitted: 11/24/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Our customers love it!" |
|
COMMENTS: This fragrance is the perfect man's fragrance. Not only does it remind men of the familiar scent from barber shops of days gone by, a lot of younger men like it a lot too. This is a standard in our lineup, and it soaps well too.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• The fragrance!
• Soaps beautifully
|
|
• Please don't change a thing!
|
|
Colleen • Michigan
Date Submitted: 11/19/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Must have male scent" |
|
COMMENTS: I haven't used it yet. I just got too excited to wait so this review is of the scent right out of the bottle. You need this for your male scent collection. It smells like your man returning from the barber and you just want to snuggle up and sniff his neck in a big comfy chair.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
|
|
Taylor • Pennsylvania
Date Submitted: 11/17/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"bay rum" |
|
COMMENTS: This is a nice bay rum FO. It isnt my favorite smelling but it isnt bad. A good FO at a Great price. Shipped fast and well packaged!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Scent, price,speed of shipping
|
|
• Nothing
|
|
Keely • North Carolina
Date Submitted: 11/05/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Great Scent but Weak in CP" |
|
COMMENTS: Great scent but extremely weak in CP soap. We follow the guidelines and the exposure level leaves a very faint smell to CP after a month of curing. Love this in beard oil and there is no acceleration or ricing issues for the soap with the recipe we used. Titanium dioxide took care of the browning from the little bit of vanilla content in the FO. Smells like a men's aftershave, maybe old spice? One of our favorites next to Black Pepper FO. We have already reordered a bigger bottle.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Face Care, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• smell
|
|
• needs to be stronger in CP
|
|
Rhianna • North Dakota
Date Submitted: 11/04/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"BEST SELLER!" |
|
COMMENTS: LOVE LOVE LOVE this smell! It's my best seller for all of my products. Will be buying this again and again.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Soap - Cold Process, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
|
|
LISA • Virginia
Date Submitted: 10/25/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"My Husband Loves it" |
|
COMMENTS: I ordered this to make shaving soap for my husband. It smells amazing OOB and even better in CP shaving soap. He loves this so much that he asked me to make him a post-shave lotion to go with it. This has become his signature fragrance.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - CPOP, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Everything
|
|
• Nothing
|
|
LISA • New York
Date Submitted: 10/06/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum" |
|
COMMENTS: Not what I expected, can't smell the orange. Sold ok, but not a customer favorite. Very strong, a little goes a long way.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
|
|
• more citrus
|
|
Jeannie • West Virginia
Date Submitted: 09/29/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"A great manly scent" |
|
COMMENTS: I was looking for a new man scent to add to my line. This has been a huge hit. I use it in soap, shave soap and lotions for gift baskets for Christmas time.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Soap - Shave Shampoo, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
|
|
Randy • New York
Date Submitted: 09/28/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Love this fragrance!" |
|
COMMENTS: Made me instantly think of my father...holds well with CP, I noticed a very slight acceleration.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Eric • Texas
Date Submitted: 09/18/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Great Bay Rum scent" |
|
COMMENTS: Some of our customers complained that it did not smell like rum lol, we had to explain what Bay Rum is :) fans of Bay Rum will like this scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - CPOP, Soap - Hot Process, Liquid Soap & Washes, Body Sprays & Perfume
|
|
|
Robin • Vermont
Date Submitted: 09/16/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"my dads aftershave" |
|
COMMENTS: I used this in cp, performed beautifully and reminded me of my dad shaving every morning.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Elena • Arkansas
Date Submitted: 08/31/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"love it" |
|
COMMENTS: I think all men love it. Great FO.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process
|
|
|
Cindy • Ohio
Date Submitted: 08/18/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Smells Like the Real Deal" |
|
COMMENTS: I used to make a Bay Rum with essential oils until the Bay got too expensive. I must say, this FO smells just like my essential oil blend. Super easy to work with. Men love it!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Easy to work with
|
|
|
|
Mary • California
Date Submitted: 07/27/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum scent" |
|
COMMENTS: Love it. Scent reminds me of dads coming out of the old barber shop after a cut n shave. A good sell in my soaps.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
|
|
Schannel • Tennessee
Date Submitted: 07/25/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"It's just ok to me but I guess that don't matter" |
|
COMMENTS: I just don't care for this fragrance, but my customer's love it so I guess that's all that counts!!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Face Care
|
|
|
Natalia • Colorado
Date Submitted: 07/22/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Like it" |
|
COMMENTS: Strong, stays in CP for months.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Nancy • Illinois
Date Submitted: 07/16/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"This is a "must have" men's scent" |
|
COMMENTS: This scent smells exactly like Royal Copenhagen cologne that my father used to wear. He has been gone since 2003 and this brought back many happy memories for me. I love this fragrance and will be putting it in my standard line for men. I can't wait until it is back in stock so I can purchase more. It is very strong and when used in hot process soap, it does take on a more "chemical" scent, but it does go away and stays true to the original scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Hot Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Scent
|
|
• Nothing
|
|
Shannon • California
Date Submitted: 07/15/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Manly Scent" |
|
COMMENTS: Nice manly scent. Very strong and a little goes a long way.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour
|
|
|
Joshua • Arizona
Date Submitted: 07/02/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Great masculine smell" |
|
COMMENTS: This scent sticks well in CP soap. No trace acceleration or ricing. Did get hot even after placing in refrigerator and got a partial gel. Next time I will freeze to cool faster and soap at cooler temps. Makes a great lotion with long lasting scent.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Face Care, Lotions, Creams & Butters
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• staying power
• ease of use
|
|
|
|
Nora • Tennessee
Date Submitted: 07/01/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Nice Manly Fragrance" |
|
COMMENTS: I made some shaving soap with this. Bay Rum was the best seller out of the three fragrances I used.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
India • Texas
Date Submitted: 06/30/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Great for Gardener's Soap" |
|
COMMENTS: It reminds me of my Grandpa. The smell brings back great memories and is the perfect scent for my "gardener's soap.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Roberta • Nebraska
Date Submitted: 06/27/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum" |
|
COMMENTS: Wow when I opened this it was a very sexy fragrance I love it! My husband smelled it and it's his favorite. Will purchase again.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Hot Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Everything
|
|
• nothing
|
|
Castlegar • British Columbia
Date Submitted: 05/13/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"SEXY MAN SCENT... WOW" |
|
COMMENTS: Most reviewers are right... its not "bay rum" its sexier. Its more on the citrus floral side than the strong SPICE side. Regardless of that, it is by far the best man smell. Sexy Man scent... no other name works for it. I'd give it 100 stars if I could. INSTANTLY hated it in the bottle, but once in the soap,omg. I rarly have a reaction like that to soap. Its AMAZING.
Just do NOT expect it to smell like traditional bay rum... its not. Its better. It did overheat on me, so suggest being prepared to throw it in the freezer. Slightly discolored, very yellow in the bottle.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• scent strength.
• Price
• everything...
|
|
• nothing
• discoloration
|
|
Beatrice • Massachusetts
Date Submitted: 04/21/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum" |
|
COMMENTS: This is the best Bay Rum ever. Soaps like a dream.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• everything
|
|
• nothing
|
|
Amy • Georgia
Date Submitted: 04/13/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Soap scent" |
|
COMMENTS: Used this last night to make a loaf of soap. Amazing very happy with the scent, cannot wait to give this one out.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Christine • North Carolina
Date Submitted: 03/15/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Masculine scent" |
|
COMMENTS: I have used this fragrance in both shaving soap and in beer soap. Both are a hit with men. I do cold process soap and find that the fragrance oil works best if tempered with warm oils and added at slight trace. I just added to my wish list to replenish my supply with my next order.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Michael • Oregon
Date Submitted: 02/26/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Spot On Bay Rum Fragrance" |
|
COMMENTS: I've tried some Bay Rum fragrances from other sources and some didn't smell how I liked, and some were flat out yucky. I took a chance on this bay rum fragrance and finally found what I was looking for! This is an awesome smelling fragrance, very spicy/clean bay rum you'd expect. Very happy about this find!
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Melt & Pour, Soap - Cold Process, Soap - Shave Shampoo
|
|
|
Marla • Texas
Date Submitted: 01/12/2015
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Bay Rum Fragrance is awesome!!!" |
|
COMMENTS: Loved this scent from the moment we opened the bottle. The men love it and my first batch of soap sold out in a week. Does not speed up trace we do a three color swirl with this and it is one of my favorite soaps.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process, Liquid Soap & Washes
|
| THINGS I LIKE |
|
THINGS I'D LIKE TO CHANGE |
• Everything
|
|
• Nothing!
|
|
Tanya • Oregon
Date Submitted: 12/10/2014
I Recommend This Product!
|
"Older men will buy homemade soap!" |
|
COMMENTS: ...If you offer Bay Rum!
My dad told me it was the original shaving cream scent and I gotta say it sold out! Older men LOVE this smell! I topped my bars with some sage powder and it was definitely a hit. scent sticks well, I highly recommend giving it a try.
|
|
PRODUCT USED IN: Soap - Cold Process
|
|
|
Deborah • Illinois
Date Submitted: 12/09/2014
I Recommend This Product!
|
"The best bay rum I have found" |
1,000+ Fragrances By Season
100% Natural Fragrance Oils
Featured Collections
Fragrance Formulator
Fragrances A to Z
Fragrances by Aromatic Notes
Fragrances by Comparable
Fragrances with Essential Oils
Retired - Special Order
Water Soluble Fragrance Oils
