Peppermint & Cocoa
"I'll still make a tester candle but all I smell is peppermint and cocoa. Disappointing because I was looking forward to the soft creaminess of the marshmallow which I cant detect OOB."
Just Scent


Just Scent
Overall rating: 4.3 / 5 from 10 reviews.
Review topics: [scent, throw, fragrance, marshmallow, dupe].
"I'll still make a tester candle but all I smell is peppermint and cocoa. Disappointing because I was looking forward to the soft creaminess of the marshmallow which I cant detect OOB."
"I was genuinely excited when my WSP order arrived yesterday. I had been counting down the days, eager to dive into making my favorite body scrub with the Peppermint & Marshmallow fragrance oil. Unfortunately, what I received was a major let down—and honestly, it hurt my feelings. Instead of the soft, sweet vanilla notes I associate with marshmallow, this fragrance smells overwhelmingly like peppermint and chocolate. It’s loud, sharp, and completely misses the mark on the cozy, creamy marshmallow vibe I was hoping for. Marshmallow should evoke warmth and softness—not a rich, chocolaty punch. I don’t even know where to begin. When my WSP order arrived yesterday, I was practically vibrating with excitement. I tore into that box like a kid on Christmas morning, ready to whip up my signature body scrub with the Peppermint & Marshmallow fragrance oil I’d been dreaming about. But what I got? A betrayal in a bottle. The moment I opened it, my heart sank. Instead of the soft, creamy vanilla hug of marshmallow wrapped in a cool peppermint breeze, I was assaulted by a loud, brash peppermint-chocolate combo that had no business calling itself “marshmallow. ” Marshmallow is supposed to be gentle. Sweet. Nostalgic. This? This was a peppermint patty crashing a slumber party. I stood there in my kitchen, stunned. Years—yes, years—since I’ve been this disappointed in a fragrance oil. I had plans. I had visions. And now I have a bottle of heartbreak masquerading as a scent. If you’re looking for a cozy, vanilla-forward marshmallow dream, keep walking. This one missed the mark so hard it’s orbiting another planet."
"Really love this scent. We used it in dual lye shave soap at 5% of total soap weight, couldn't be happier. Don't worry about too much smoke or tobacco being overpowering."
"This is a perfect dupe! A best seller for us through the Fall and Winter. Excellent in my para soy blend candles and tarts."
"I agree, perfect dupe. Performs great in our sprays and wax. Have request year round for this one."
"Can't say enough about this oil. It is super strong and has an amazing scent throw in 50-50 soy."
"Strong scent throw in my straight paraffin wax. Also does well in room sprays and linen sprays. This is a favorite at my shop."
"If you've smelled the original version, you've smelled this one. It's dead on! I can't wait until the calendar flips over to September to fire this one up. It's strong in my parrafin and fills the house up with a wonderful fall fragrance."
"Hi thank you so much. I have to purchase many of these candles from a well known business just so I can have them for the year as they are seasonal. I've tried to make candles with this fragrance from other companies. Your fragrance almost had me in joyful tears, I can enjoy this throughout the year. I made the candle let it cure for about five days and when I lit it within three minutes the throw was so strong. thank you again."
"Awesome scent throw in soy and soy blend melts, perfect duplication of the original."
Percentage Calculator
Easily convert recipes from formula weights to percentages, allowing for scalability.
lye calculator
Perfect for helping you in soap making and producing handmade soap.
fragrance calculator
Find the right amount of fragrance, flavor, or essential oils to safely add to your handmade products.
Batch Calculator
Easily convert a recipe from percentages to formula weights.